
"The spray I used on my daughter's high chair every day came joint last out of nine. I'd bought it because it ""kills 99.9%"". If you've got a baby or a toddler and you wipe the high chair tray with an antibacterial spray after every meal, please read this to the end. The same goes if your little one crawls across the kitchen floor all afternoon and then puts her fingers in her mouth. I was doing exactly that, five or six times a day, and I thought it was the most careful thing a parent could do. A bit about me first. I write about home and health for a living, which makes this a slightly embarrassing story to tell. My daughter is a toddler now. She started solids a little while ago, and since then our kitchen has had the same rhythm every day. Porridge in the morning, which ends up on the tray, on her sleeves and somehow in her hair. Something on toast at lunch. Then a long afternoon on the kitchen floor, where she crawls from the cupboard with the pans to the bin she isn't allowed to touch, and puts everything she finds straight into her mouth. So I cleaned. A lot. The bottle lived on the counter next to the kettle, because it was quicker than putting it back under the sink. After breakfast, a few squirts on the high chair tray, a wipe, done. After lunch, the table where she leans her arms and her whole face. In the afternoon, a quick spray on the patch of floor in front of the fridge where she always ends up. I never counted, but if I'm honest it was five or six times on most days. And I chose that spray on purpose. When she was born I stood in the cleaning aisle and picked the one that said it kills 99.9% of germs, because that felt like the responsible choice. A baby, germs, a bottle that promises to kill them. It never crossed my mind that there might be a question to ask about it. Nobody else asked it either. My mum used the same kind of spray when I was little. The health visitor never mentioned it. At baby group, the only cleaning conversation we ever had was about which wipes get Weetabix off a wall. What changed it was a link my sister sent me late one evening, with no message apart from ""have you seen this?"" It was a study that followed 2,022 babies from birth. The researchers asked parents how often they cleaned with everyday cleaning products when their babies were three to four months old. Then they checked on the children again at age three. In the homes that used cleaning products the most, 65% more children had asthma by their third birthday than in the homes that used them least. I read that sentence twice. Then I read the part where the researchers explained why babies are hit hardest. They spend almost all their time indoors. They breathe faster than adults do. And they touch every surface around them. I was sitting on the sofa, and I could see the high chair from where I was sitting. The tray was still a bit damp from the last wipe. I texted my sister back: ""That's every surface in our kitchen."" She replied: ""Exactly. Turn the bottle round."" So the next morning, before my daughter woke up, I took the spray off the counter and read the back of the label properly for the first time. Line by line. And because I write about this sort of thing for a living, I didn't stop there. I picked eight more of the most popular sprays you can buy and read every single label. The first thing I learned surprised me more than anything else. The part of a spray that actually cleans is simple. It's a soap-like ingredient that grabs grease with one end and water with the other, so the dirt lifts off the surface and goes into your cloth. That's it. That's what gets porridge off a tray. The worrying ingredients are the ones that get added on top of that. And they're added so the bottle can promise you something a soap can't. The biggest one is the germ-killer itself. In most everyday antibacterial sprays it's a family of chemicals called quats. On the label you'll usually see benzalkonium chloride, or another name that ends in ""ammonium chloride"". That's the ingredient that lets the bottle say it kills 99.9% of bacteria. In 2023, a team of scientists called quats ""a chemical class of emerging concern"". Health and safety researchers have linked them to asthma in professional cleaners. And they're highly irritating to the skin. I sat at the kitchen table with that bottle in my hand and thought about where I'd been spraying it. On the tray she eats her porridge off. On the table she lays her cheek on when she's tired. On the floor she crawls across right before her hand goes in her mouth. Several times a day, every day, to kill germs that a plain soap-like cleaner and a cloth would have wiped away anyway. That's when the penny dropped for me. A kitchen table isn't an operating theatre. It needs cleaning, not sterilising. The germ-killer wasn't the only thing I kept finding. There were three more. Bleach, in the sprays sold ""with bleach"". In a study of more than 9,000 schoolchildren, children whose parents cleaned with bleach at home had more flu, tonsillitis and other infections, and the researchers think the fumes irritate young airways enough to let infections take hold. A cheap group of preservatives called isothiazolinones, listed as MI, MCI or BIT. In 2013, dermatologists warned of an ""epidemic"" of skin allergy caused by them. Once someone has become allergic, it stays that way for life. Not something I want on the surfaces my daughter touches with her hands and cheeks all day. And what I started calling the harsh helpers: caustic soda and phosphates, solvents, EDTA and dyes. They make a spray cut grease a bit faster or look nicer in the bottle. None of them does anything for your family that a gentler ingredient couldn't do. On its own, each of these is usually used in a small amount. The trouble is that they rarely come on their own. A typical antibacterial spray combines two to four of them. And we use it several times a day, at the height of our baby's face, in the home where she spends almost all of her time. That's exactly the pattern the asthma study measured. When my husband came home I showed him the bottle and the study. He listened, and then he said what I'd been half expecting. ""But she puts everything in her mouth. Don't we want to kill the germs?"" It's a fair question, and it's the one I'd have asked a week earlier. But feeding bottles are something you sterilise. A high chair tray, a table or a kitchen floor needs cleaning. When you wipe with a cleaning spray and a cloth, the dirt, the food and the germs sitting in them lift off and go into the cloth, and the cloth goes into the wash. Nothing has to be left behind on the tray to do that job. He turned the bottle over in his hands for a while and then said, ""So what are we supposed to use instead?"" That question is the reason I ended up testing nine of them. I'll be honest about what this was and what it wasn't. I'm not a doctor and I didn't run a lab. The asthma study counted cleaning in homes; it didn't test one particular bottle. What I could do was read every label carefully and use every spray in a real kitchen with a real toddler in it. So I picked nine sprays that are easy to buy. The four best-selling household names. Three eco brands. A refill brand that comes through your letterbox. And one more that a friend had mentioned, which I'll come back to. Then I asked every label the same question: would I spray this on my daughter's high chair tray? That turned into five simple tests, one point each. No germ-killers. No bleach or ammonia. No allergy-causing preservatives. No harsh helpers or dyes. And no plastic bottle to throw away every time you run out. After that, I used every single one for a week in our own kitchen. On the high chair, the table, the counter and the hob. The big names did worst, and I didn't expect them to do quite this badly. None of them scored more than three out of five. Flash leaves the germ-killer out of its everyday spray, which is to its credit. But it's preserved with benzisothiazolinone, one of the preservatives the dermatologists warned about, and it comes in a new plastic bottle every time. Three out of five. Cif's multi-purpose sprays had the highest dose of benzalkonium chloride in my whole test, and the antibacterial Power & Shine adds caustic soda, sodium carbonate and a phosphate on top. Two out of five. Zoflora combines benzalkonium chloride with EDTA. And here's the line that made me put the bottle down: its own label tells you to keep pets off treated areas until they're completely dry. If that's the advice for your cat, think about your baby crawling across that same floor. Two out of five. And the spray on my counter, the one I'd been using on her tray since the day she started solids? Dettol. The best-known antibacterial spray of all, and the clearest example of everything I'd learned: benzalkonium chloride, a glycol ether and monoethanolamine. Even its refills are concentrates in small plastic bottles. Two out of five. Joint last. I'd picked that bottle because I thought it was the safe one. The eco brands did a lot better, and I want to be fair to them. Ecover Zero is made for sensitive skin and was the closest of the supermarket sprays to my winner on what's inside, but every time you finish it there's another plastic bottle and trigger in the bin, and you're carrying home 500 ml of mostly water. Bio-D has one of the shortest labels I found, but it's also a plastic bottle with plastic refills. Method uses lactic acid instead of a quat, which I liked, but it's still a plastic habit. And Smol's letterbox tablets are good value, but the formula contains a colourant that does nothing for your surfaces. Four out of five, all four of them. Good, but not quite there. Only one passed all five tests. It was the one my friend had mentioned, and it surprised me the most, because it isn't really a spray you buy at all. You won't find it on a supermarket shelf either. The thing I was most sceptical about was whether something that gentle would actually clean, because I half expected it to mean more scrubbing. It didn't. One wipe took dried-on porridge off the high chair tray and the grease off the hob front, and the counter was left without a single streak. Ten minutes later my daughter was back in her high chair with a piece of toast. And for the first time since she started solids, I didn't think twice about what was on that tray. My husband noticed the difference before I said anything. The bottle on the counter had changed, and he picked it up, read the back and said, ""That's it? That's all that's in it?"" That's all that's in it. It cleans with what's needed and nothing more. I'm writing all of this down because I know how many parents are standing exactly where I was, holding a bottle that promises to protect their baby. If you wipe the high chair tray with antibacterial spray after every meal… If the bottle next to your kettle says it kills 99.9% of germs, and that's exactly why you bought it… If your little one crawls across the kitchen floor all afternoon and then puts her fingers in her mouth… If you clean the same few surfaces five or six times a day and never once looked at the back of the label… If you've switched to an eco spray and assumed that settled it… If someone told you that with a baby in the house, you can never be too careful with germs… …then it's worth turning your spray around before you wipe the tray again tomorrow morning. If none of that sounds like you, and you already use something you're completely happy with, that's wonderful. You don't need the article. For everyone else, I've written up the whole test: all nine sprays, the five tests, what's in each bottle and how each one scored. There's a Black Friday sale on my number one right now, and it comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee. The best test is the one I did. Use it for a month on the high chair, the table and the floor your baby crawls on. If it doesn't clean the way you want, or you're simply not happy, you get your money back. Which spray passed all five tests, and how the big names scored one by one, is in the article 👇 P.S. Do one thing tonight before you clear up after dinner. Turn your spray around and look for benzalkonium chloride, or anything ending in ""ammonium chloride"". If it's there, that's the ingredient that lets the bottle say ""kills 99.9%"", and it's on the tray your baby eats from. The one spray that passed all five tests doesn't need it. It's all in the article 👇