
The morning after my son's wedding, I counted eleven of my own eyelashes on a cotton pad. I'd worn waterproof mascara because I knew I'd cry. I did, through the vows, the father-son dance, and the toast his best man gave about the summer they wrecked my car. The mascara held up beautifully. Not a smudge in any photo. Then the next morning I stood at the hotel sink and tried to take it off. Waterproof doesn't come off with water, which I suppose is the point. I used the makeup remover, then a wipe, then more remover. I scrubbed. And when I finally looked down at the cotton pad, there they were. Little black curves, stuck in the smears. I counted them. Eleven. I'm 61. My lashes had already gotten thinner and shorter over the past few years. I couldn't afford to lose eleven of them for one wedding. I want to tell you everything I tried before that morning and after it, because I've since found out a lot of women are doing the same things. For years my answer to thinning lashes was more coats. One wasn't enough anymore, so I'd do three. By the third, my lashes stuck together in little clumps. My friend Barb at book club leaned over one night and said, "Honey, you've got spider legs." She meant it kindly. I went to the bathroom and picked at my lashes with a fingernail for five minutes. So I tried an expensive one. $34 from the department store, with a big fat brush that promised "volume." The brush was so big it couldn't reach half my lashes, especially the short ones at the inner corners. And by 3 in the afternoon, little black specks had flaked off and settled under my eyes. In the car mirror I looked like I hadn't slept in a week. Then the waterproof phase, which ended at that hotel sink. After the wedding, I tried a lash serum my niece swore by. My eyelids went red and itchy within four days. I stopped. I tried false lashes once, for my fortieth high school reunion. The glue stung, one corner came loose during dinner, and I spent the evening holding my head at an odd angle so nobody would notice. Then, for about a year, I gave up. No mascara at all. That was its own problem. Without it, my eyes just disappeared. My face looked washed out. My granddaughter, who is seven and has no filter, asked me if I was feeling sick. I said no. She said, "Your eyes look small." I didn't know what was left to try. Every option either clumped, flaked, irritated my eyes, or pulled my lashes out at the end of the day. The answer came from somewhere I didn't expect. My eye doctor. I'd gone in for my yearly exam and mentioned my eyes had been dry and gritty. She had me put my chin on the machine and looked at the surface of my eye under the bright light for a long time. Then she said, "Do you wear mascara?" I said I used to, most of my life, and still did sometimes. She turned the screen toward me. There were tiny dark flecks on the surface of my eye and along my lash line. "That's mascara," she said. "It flakes off and ends up in your eye. I see it every week, especially in women over fifty." Then she explained the thing nobody at a makeup counter had ever told me. After fifty, lashes get finer and shorter. Most mascaras are designed for the lashes of a twenty-five-year-old. They get their length and volume from piling on pigment, so on finer lashes you need more coats, and more coats means clumps, and the excess flakes off during the day. Waterproof formulas are even harder on older lashes, because they don't come off without scrubbing, and scrubbing is what pulls the fine ones out. She wrote on the back of an appointment card, the way I imagine she writes everything. Not waterproof. Water-based. A small wand that can reach the short lashes. Comes off with warm water. Gentle enough for sensitive eyes. I went home with that card and did what I always do. I made a project of it. I read labels in the drugstore for an hour. Most were waterproof, or didn't say. The ones with small wands were for "precision," meant for bottom lashes. Nothing said it was made for older lashes. That night I joined an online group for women over fifty and searched "mascara." There were hundreds of comments. One product name came up again and again. PrimeLash, from a company called Prime Prometics that only makes products for women over fifty. One comment said, "I'm 59 and threw out all my old mascaras, even the expensive one." Another said, "First mascara in ten years that doesn't end up under my eyes by noon." I checked it against the card. Not waterproof, but water-resistant. Water-based. A slim, tapered wand. Hypoallergenic. Washes off easily. I ordered it. The wand was the first thing I noticed. It's slimmer than I expected, tapered at the tip. For the first time in years, I could reach the tiny lashes at the inner corner, the ones I'd stopped bothering with because no brush could grab them. Two coats. It separated every lash instead of gluing them together. My lashes looked longer and fuller than they had in a long time, and they still looked like mine. No spider legs. At 5 o'clock I checked the car mirror out of habit. Nothing under my eyes. No specks. No shadow. That night I did the part I'd been dreading. Warm water and a cotton pad, nothing else. It came off in a couple of gentle passes. I looked down at the pad. Mascara. No lashes. I've worn it most days since. I've stopped finding lashes on the cotton pad. My eyes don't feel gritty by the afternoon, and at my next exam my doctor didn't find any flecks. She just said, "Whatever you changed, keep it." I'll be honest about one thing, because it's what I'd want to know. It isn't waterproof. It's water-resistant, so it holds up through tears and a hot day, but I wouldn't wear it swimming. For me that's the whole point. Last month was my granddaughter's First Communion. I cried, of course. I always do. In the photos my eyes are open and bright and there isn't a smudge on me. My granddaughter looked up at me in the church parking lot and said, "Grandma, your eyes look pretty." The next morning I washed it off with warm water and looked at the cotton pad. No lashes. If you've been finding them on yours, I understand. It's called PrimeLash Mascara, and they give a full refund if you don't like it. Here's the one I ordered. The link is below. P.S. Check your own cotton pad tonight when you take your mascara off. Count what's on it. That number tells you more about your mascara than anything on the box.