Blue Sea

To find out, listen to the audio series 'Hearts in the Crossfire' (FREE for a limited period of time). Click on the link below to download the Pocket FM app, now!

Ad Copy

The only woman with answers was dead on the library floor. She had come to my antique shop and called out my dead father’s name. The name that has been buried for nearly thirty years since my father vanished one day. I never saw him, never heard of him until she called his name. I wanted to know more about him and went to her house the next morning, only to find her lying dead on the library floor. But I'm getting ahead of myself. Three weeks before I found Constance Vane's body, I was standing on a sidewalk in Manhattan at eight forty-seven in the morning, holding divorce papers that were still warm from the printer. My name had been reduced to a legal term. My marriage to a financial clause. Seventeen years of my life appraised, divided, and initialed in triplicate. I did not cry. I did not call a lawyer. I called my sister Petra, who told me, in the same tone she uses for weather forecasts, that I should "process this with Owen present." I hung up. I walked into my office. I told my boss Vivienne I was taking personal time. Then I opened my laptop, found a one-way flight to England, and booked it before I could ask myself a single sensible question. That was the first impulsive thing I'd done in seventeen years. It would not be the last. Saltfen. My father had brought me here once, when I was seven years old. One perfect summer. Cobblestones under patent-leather shoes. Salt air so thick you could chew it. His hand rough and warm and absolutely certain wrapped around mine. He left our family not long after that summer. No warning. No forwarding address. His name became a word my mother refused to say. I told myself I came back for fresh air. For perspective. For a clean break from a city that had started to feel like someone else's dream. I told myself that. I almost believed it. I found the store on my third morning. I wasn't looking for it. I turned a corner on the high street and stopped walking. It smelled like my father's shop. I leased it the same afternoon, using the same pen I'd signed my divorce papers with. I moved in a dog that wasn't mine. I made one true friend my neighbor Bette, who arrived with a bone-crushing hug and a pot of tea and asked no questions at all. I met a baker named Rowan, whose smile did something embarrassing to my cardiovascular system. I painted the walls. I acquired stock. I opened for business. For approximately eleven days, my life was quietly, unexpectedly wonderful. Then Constance Vane walked into my store. She was eighty-something, regal as a sovereign, and she looked at me the way people look at a photograph they weren't expecting to find. She said she had antiques at her estate that needed valuing. She said she trusted me because I was new to town and didn't know her history. She said I was welcome to come for breakfast at Harewick Estate the following morning. Then she said five words that unraveled everything. *You look just like Elliot.* Elliot Cole. My father. The man whose name had been banned in my own household for thirty years. She was gone before I could ask a single question. By the following morning, she was dead. Let me tell you what Saltfen looked like to a woman in freefall. It looked like a postcard of somewhere that had never heard the word "divorce." Candy-colored storefronts. A harbor with actual fishing boats. A high street so prettily cobbled it seemed designed by someone who'd only ever read about rain, never experienced it. I arrived at dusk with a duffel bag, no return ticket, and the particular recklessness of someone who has stopped caring what happens next. Every hotel in town was full. Easter weekend. I hadn't thought to check. The innkeeper at The Anchor House looked at me the way people look at the last passenger to board a sinking lifeboat. But a man named Noel Farris overheard and offered me a cottage. Tern Cottage. It sat on a cliff above the harbor, and when I saw it silhouetted against the last of the light all dark stone and fairytale chimney and the sea churning gray below I thought: yes. That is where I am supposed to be. It wasn't ready. There were cobwebs and a radiator that required negotiation and a window latch Noel fixed with a paperclip. I didn't care. I had no plan. That was new. Seventeen years with Owen had been a relentless calendar of five-year projections and quarterly performance reviews applied, somehow, to a marriage. I had forgotten what it felt like to not know what came next. It felt terrifying. It also felt like breathing. My sister Petra phoned every other day to remind me I was having a breakdown. My mother sent emails asking whether I'd considered that Owen was simply "going through a phase." I watched my visa application status and tried not to make too many life-altering decisions in the same forty-eight-hour window. I failed at that. Spectacularly. On my third morning, I walked past a shuttered antique shop on the high street and stopped. The smell hit me first. Cedar and wood polish and something older underneath that particular dustiness of objects that have outlived their owners. My father's shop in Brooklyn had smelled exactly like that. He had loved antiques the way some people love music: not for the objects themselves but for what they contained. Every piece had a story, he said. Every piece remembered something. I pressed my face to the gap in the window paper and looked inside. The owner, Edmund, found me there. He was a red-eyed, exhausted man who explained, after a silence in which I clearly wasn't going to pretend I hadn't been peering into his store like a burglar, that his previous tenants had abandoned the lease overnight. Left everything behind. Bills unpaid. The beautiful light fixture still hanging from the ceiling. He was trying to sell the property to cover the loss, but no buyer wanted a former antiques shop on a coastal high street. I heard my own voice say: *What if I leased it instead?* I had no business experience. I had a background in interior design assistance and a divorce settlement that hadn't cleared yet. What I had, overwhelmingly, was the feeling that this was the only right thing I had done in years. Edmund and his wife Ruth gave me the lease the same afternoon I asked for it. I signed with a ballpoint pen I'd been carrying in my coat pocket since the morning the divorce papers arrived. It seemed important to use the same pen. To close one thing by opening another. I moved in. I sourced stock a trip to London with Bette in the back of a secondhand Audi with a temperamental heater, an entire day moving through dealers and auction houses, Bette narrating the history of every neighborhood we passed through with the enthusiasm of a woman who'd been waiting years for someone to drag her back to the city. I opened Maren's Antiques on a Tuesday morning in early April with my heart in my throat and the particular terror of someone who has staked everything on an impulse. My first customer was a Danish couple who bought a ceramic vase for forty pounds. Rowan the baker from the patisserie across the street gave me a thumbs-up from his window. I felt more proud in that moment than I had in seventeen years. Then Barnaby arrived. He simply walked in one morning while the door was open and sat down in the middle of the shop floor as if he'd always lived there. Rowan recognized him immediately. The dog had belonged to the store's previous tenants the ones who'd vanished overnight, who'd left that beautiful light fixture hanging, who'd left behind enough evidence of a hasty departure to suggest they hadn't been leaving so much as *fleeing*. A call to the RSPCA delivered the news with all the gentleness of a cold tap: the couple had died in a car accident. The same week they'd abandoned the store. Rowan and I sat with that information for a moment. He said, slowly: *They were in a hurry.* I said: *They were running from something.* He looked at me. I looked at him. Neither of us said what we were both thinking that whatever they'd been running from was still here. Still in Saltfen. Still, possibly, in the building where their dog now lived. Selene Harker had wanted this store. She'd had an arrangement with Edmund a verbal agreement, nothing binding, the kind of understanding that operates on the assumption that nothing will disrupt it. I had disrupted it. I had arrived from New York with no advance notice and no awareness that I was stepping into the middle of something, and I had leased the store she'd spent months planning to expand into. She wore the same shade of hair dye I did. We were built similarly. We had what I could only describe as an uncanny physical resemblance, which made our mutual antagonism feel like something out of folklore as if one of us was the original and one was the shadow. She moved her sound system to the wall we shared. She knocked over my trash cans. She put her sandwich board in front of my door. I could live with the trash cans and the sandwich board. I could not live, it turned out, with the music. I went next door and told her to turn it down. She feigned innocence with the composure of someone who had rehearsed this exact scene. She turned the volume down with a performance of reluctant compliance that made me want to put my head through the wall. I went back to my store. Constance Vane was gone. She had come in while I was dealing with Selene. An elderly woman, regal and unhurried, who introduced herself as Constance Vane of Harewick Estate. She'd wanted a valuation of her antiques. She trusted me, she'd said, because I was new because I didn't know her or her history. She had looked at me for a long moment and then said the thing she'd clearly come to say: *You look just like Elliot.* Elliot Cole. My father. The man my mother refused to name, whose absence had shaped the geography of my entire childhood. Here was a woman in a coastal English town who knew him well enough to see him in my face. I had missed her. I'd been next door arguing about speaker placement, and I had missed her. She was coming for breakfast the following morning, I reminded myself. I had all night to wait. All night to sleep, which I did not do, and to form questions, which I did in abundance, and to dream which I did, and which I wished I hadn't. In the dream I was seven years old again, and my hand was in my father's. We were walking the high street this high street, these exact cobblestones. His face was obscured by the sun behind his head, but I knew him by his hand. The roughness of his palm. The absolute certainty in his grip. A woman approached us and said: *Well if it isn't Elliot Cole.* I knew her. She was the clerk from the antiques shop where we used to go. The same shop that smelled of cedar. The same shop I was now living in. I woke at three in the morning with my heart hammering and sweat on the back of my neck. Barnaby lifted his head and looked at me with what I can only describe as professional concern. I lay in the dark and thought about my father. About a woman who'd known him well enough to be trusted by him. About whatever it was that had happened in Saltfen one summer thirty years ago. I thought: *tomorrow morning, Constance will explain everything.* I thought that until I found her. The front door was ajar. Barnaby bolted in before I could stop him. I heard his barking deepen, go urgent, go strange. I followed him through the entrance hall and down the corridor toward the sound. The library door was open. She was on the floor between the reading chair and the fireplace, one arm extended as if she'd reached for something on her way down. The books on the shelves hadn't moved. The room hadn't been disturbed. She looked almost peaceful, which was the wrong word entirely, and I would learn later how wrong. Superintendent Ray Denholm arrived with DCI Fiona Adler twenty minutes after I called. He was a bulky, incurious man who looked at me the way he'd clearly been trained to look at everyone within the first sixty seconds of a crime scene: as if they were guilty of something and the only question was what. He told me it was a homicide. He told me the crime scene investigators were on their way. He told me I was free to go home. Then he told me not to leave town. I didn't sleep. I lay in the dark with Barnaby's weight against my shins and tried to build a version of events in which I was not, in any meaningful sense, the most logical suspect in the murder of Constance Vane. I could not build that version. I had found the body. I had been inside the property. I had no alibi I'd driven there alone, early in the morning, with no witnesses other than my dog. And I had a business reason, freshly established, to want access to the estate's contents. From where Superintendent Denholm was standing, I probably looked like a textbook case. The town found out by the following morning. Small towns operate on a kind of ambient information network that makes formal journalism look slow. I could feel it the moment I arrived at the store a shift in the quality of the glances. People who had previously nodded or smiled now found the middle distance extremely interesting as I passed. Rowan appeared behind me as I fumbled with the key in the lock. His face was the most welcome thing I'd seen in forty-eight hours. He pulled me into a hug the kind that says *I am not one of them* and I felt something in my chest unknot that I hadn't realized was wound so tight. Then the phone rang. I answered it. A voice I didn't recognize said: *Murderer.* Then the call ended. The light on the answering machine was blinking. More messages. Rowan gently put his hand over mine and pulled the cord from the wall. I said: *How does everyone know already?* He said: *Small town.* He said it with the flat acceptance of someone who grew up in one and understood it as a condition rather than a flaw. The man on the bench was pretending to use his phone. I watched him for long enough to be certain. Standard earbuds don't loop around the ear that way. The wire from his earpiece disappeared into the collar of his jacket and did not connect to any visible device. He was not listening to music. He was receiving instructions. Superintendent Denholm had posted a plainclothes officer outside my store. I stood at the window and let that land. The police didn't think I was a witness who happened to find a body. They thought I was the killer keeping tabs on her crime scene. They weren't investigating this murder so much as waiting for me to incriminate myself. Rowan said carefully: *What are you going to do?* I said: *I'm going to figure out who actually killed her.* Bette had been in the pub. She said it plainly, the way she said everything the same way she'd handed me tea the day we met, without preamble or ceremony. Selene had been there. Selene had told anyone willing to listen that Maren Cole had killed Constance Vane for her antiques. I stood on the cottage step and heard myself go very quiet. Bette said: *I know it isn't true.* I said: *I know it isn't true.* She said: *So what are we going to do about it?* That night, we sat at my kitchen table with Bette's shepherd's pie and built a strategy. She was brisk and practical about it in the manner of someone who had survived enough of life to understand that indignation was a luxury and action was the point. She had lost her son to active service and her husband to years of slow grief afterward. She knew the difference between situations you could survive and situations you couldn't, and she had decided, apparently, that I was the former. The strategy: investigate. The news articles gave me two things. First: no forced entry. Constance had known her killer. She had let them in or they had a key. The library door had not been forced. She had had no defensive wounds, which meant the end came quickly, which meant she had not seen it coming. Second: family. An older sister with Alzheimer's. Three children. Sebastian the eldest, successful, based in New Zealand, the type who operated through lawyers and boardrooms. Rowena a "spinster CEO," her words reportedly cool and corporate even in grief. And Miles youngest, described as "estranged," running a surfing business in Portugal. Three children. None of them apparently in the will. That detail didn't appear in the articles. I learned it later. But when I thought about those three children wealthy, entitled, cut off from an aristocratic estate the picture they formed had a distinct shape. Leonard Pryce opened the door before I'd finished knocking. He was Constance's valet I'd gathered that much from the brief research I'd done. He had the look of a man in the middle of a great many things at once: grief, logistics, and the specific exhaustion of serving someone who had just died and left an enormous estate in his charge. He looked at me and his eyes did a quick calculation. He said: *You're the one the police think did it.* I said: *I didn't.* He said: *That's what someone who did would say.* And then he said he had an alibi, which was more than could be said for me, and he closed the door in my face. I stood on the step and thought: he's running errands for a dead woman. He picks up her prescriptions I'd seen his name in the news. But Constance had come to my store herself, in person, rather than sending him. Why hadn't she trusted him with that particular errand? He was hiding something. I wasn't sure yet what. I dialed the number for the police station. I put on the worst British accent in the history of recorded performance and told the receptionist I was Rowena Vane calling to speak with Superintendent Denholm regarding her mother. The receptionist transferred me without hesitation. There was a pause. Then Denholm's voice slow, deliberately unhurried, with the particular quality of a man who has been doing this long enough to recognize a bad accent from several counties away. He said: *Really.* Then he said: *Miss Cole, I know it's you. Your accent is terrible.* Then he accidentally told me that the real Rowena Vane was at the station right now. I thanked him in my own voice and hung up. Rowena Vane was a contained, angular woman who wore her grief the way she wore her suit tailored, managed, giving nothing away unnecessarily. She saw me waiting by the steps and regarded me with the specific wariness of someone who had been told my name. I introduced myself. I explained, quickly and with as much credibility as I could assemble in under sixty seconds, that I was the one who had found her mother, that I was not the police's suspect of choice but rather their convenient one, and that I believed someone inside the family structure might have had reason to harm Constance. She looked at me for a long time. She said: *Mother trusted almost no one.* Then she said something I hadn't expected: her mother had called her the night before she died. She had sounded frightened. She had said something about the children not Rowena specifically, but *the children* and about something that belonged to them that didn't belong to them anymore. She said: *I don't know what she meant.* I thought I might. Constance's will, as it turned out, was not a secret. The legal summary had been filed in public record. The estate Harewick Manor, its contents, the land had been left in its entirety to Leonard Pryce, her valet of twenty-two years. The children received nothing except the contents of their childhood playroom. I sat with that for a moment. Three adult children of a wealthy aristocrat. Cut out entirely. Given back their old toys. And whatever had belonged to them when they were children that was theirs to claim. Which meant they could legally enter the property to retrieve it. Which meant the clock was the key. Leonard came to me with a proposition the following week Constance, before she died, had arranged to have the contents of Harewick Estate appraised and auctioned. She had wanted the proceeds to go to charity. She had designated a specific list of items for valuation. And she had asked, through a separate arrangement made before her death, that those items be moved to a secure location until the auction could be organized. The secure location, Leonard explained, was my store. I said: *You want to move a dead woman's antiques into my shop.* He said: *I want to honor her wishes.* I looked at the list. The jewels. Several paintings. A Victorian writing desk. And the grandfather clock a piece from the main hall that had, in living memory, stood in the children's playroom before being moved to Constance's study. The clock was not in the children's playroom at the time of Constance's death. Which meant it was not legally theirs to claim. Which meant if something was hidden inside it they couldn't get to it. Unless they broke in. They arrived in two cars. I was at the estate with Leonard when we heard the tires on the gravel drive. He went to the window, looked out, and said with the flat shock of someone trying very hard not to show shock: *It's them. The children.* They didn't wait to be invited. Sebastian was tall and sun-bronzed, the kind of man who'd spent enough time in a New York boardroom to treat every room as a negotiation. He had papers. There was a clause in the will items from their childhood, they were entitled to access. He waved the documents at Leonard with the practiced confidence of someone who'd had a lawyer find this particular loophole months ago. Rowena was watchful and sharp, her grief managed into something that looked almost clinical from the outside. She looked at me and said: *The antiques dealer. The one the police think killed Mother.* Miles was the youngest bronze-skinned, recently arrived from Portugal, the kind of man whose previous crimes, according to Leonard's later accounting, had been gambling debts and estrangement rather than violence. He'd found his footing in recent years, built his surfing business, settled down. He mostly looked like he wanted to be somewhere else. Leonard said carefully that they were welcome to their childhood belongings, with one stipulation: a lawyer needed to be present, and a full itemized ledger prepared, to document exactly what they were claiming. Sebastian looked at the ledger request the way he'd look at a parking ticket. I looked at the grandfather clock in the corner of the room. The one that had been moved from the playroom to the study. The one not on the children's list. The one none of them could legally take. Rowan listened to everything. He was good at that the particular listening of someone who isn't planning what to say next, just absorbing what you're telling them. We'd been developing something I couldn't quite name yet: not a friendship and not a romance but something in the overlap between the two, every conversation a little longer than the one before it. I told him about the will. About the children's playroom. About the clock that had been moved. He said: *What do you think is inside it?* I said: *Something worth killing for.* He was quiet for a moment. Then he said: *It can't be easy moving a grandfather clock on your own.* I said: *It can't be moved by one person.* He said: *So we're not looking for the children working together.* I said: *We're looking for one of them. Alone. After hours.* He looked at me steadily. Lace, he said and then seemed to notice he'd used the shortened name and looked very briefly like he'd surprised himself. I noticed it too. I said nothing. There were more urgent things. Bette had done her own digging. She was a woman of sixty-something who had lived in Saltfen long enough to know where every skeleton was stored metaphorically, and in at least two cases that she declined to elaborate on, somewhat more literally. She knew the Vane family by reputation, knew the estate's history, knew the local rumor infrastructure well enough to extract specific facts without anyone realizing they'd shared them. The Drummond-Holt painting, she told me, was missing. Lady Cecily Drummond-Holt had been one of Constance's ancestors, a minor aristocrat whose portraits had become, in the last twenty years, extraordinarily valuable. Not museum-famous. Not auction-house-famous. The particular fame of things that connoisseurs know about and the general public doesn't which makes them harder to trace and easier to move discreetly. One of her miniature paintings had been in the Vane family's possession for generations. Constance had it catalogued. But it wasn't on the list of items to be auctioned. It wasn't on the item's inventory at all. I thought about a clock. I thought about what fits inside an ornate, eighteenth-century grandfather clock when you remove the weights. I thought about a painting small enough to be a miniature and valuable enough to be worth committing murder over. I thought about the children who had grown up with that clock in their playroom. Barnaby heard it before I did. He stopped at the entrance to the back room and went still the particular stillness of an animal whose threat assessment has already concluded while yours is still loading. His head was low. The growl started deep in his chest, barely audible. I heard the crash. The back door had been forced. The wood around the lock was shattered, the kind of damage a crowbar makes when you lean your full weight behind it. A masked figure straightened from behind the safe and moved. I froze. Barnaby did not. He crossed the room in the kind of sustained, low blur that English Shepherds were bred for, and clamped his jaws around the intruder's ankle. The intruder cried out a deep voice, unmistakably male and reached for something on the floor. A crowbar. Long and heavy and already moving upward. I shouted Barnaby's name. He let go. He knew my commanding voice from my panicked one, and I am grateful for that every time I think about it. He released the man's ankle and stepped back. The intruder stumbled. The arm with the crowbar dropped to his side. Then he ran, through the broken door and into the dark. They'd sent Denholm himself. He stood on my pavement and looked at the splintered door with the expression of a man who had already decided on the narrative before examining the scene. He said my name with the flat bob of his head that I was beginning to understand was his version of punctuation. He took in the broken door. The glass. The safe, untouched. The clock, undisturbed. Barnaby, sitting at my feet with the alert bearing of a dog who has recently done something professionally satisfying. Denholm said: *Can you confirm nothing was taken?* I said: *Nothing was taken.* He wrote something in his notebook. He did not say: *We're sorry this happened.* He did not say: *We'll increase patrol frequency.* He wrote in his notebook with the careful penmanship of a man documenting a statement he was planning to use against the person giving it. Selene said this was my fault. She said it with the energy of someone who had been waiting for permission to say it for days. The break-in proved it: I attracted criminals. Saltfen had been quiet before I came along. Now there was murder and break-ins and police notices, and wasn't that all quite convenient for the woman the police already suspected. Rowan, who happened to be there, reminded her that she'd had her own break-in a few years back, that the whole town had rallied around her rather than blaming her, and perhaps she might want to consider doing the same. Selene looked at him with the particular coldness of someone who had once expected warmth from him and had long since stopped expecting it. She said: *Things change, Thomas.* She left. Rowan looked at me. I looked at him. The clock stood behind us in the back room, keeping its own time. DCI Adler came back without Denholm. That told me something. She confirmed that the brothers, Sebastian and Miles, had been questioned about the break-in. Both had confirmed alibis. Sebastian had been at a pub in town multiple witnesses, CCTV. Miles had been in his hotel, key card confirmed. She said it carefully, like she was laying down a fact without the commentary she wasn't allowed to give. I said: *Both brothers. Confirmed.* She said: *Yes.* I said: *What about Rowena?* She said she couldn't comment on that. I said: *Understood.* She left. I stood in the store. The theory I'd been building quietly rearranged itself. If the brothers were out if both of them were accounted for then the figure in the back room, the deep voice, the crowbar that had been someone else. Or one of the brothers had paid someone else to do it. Or my theory was wrong about which son. Or my theory was wrong in a way I hadn't found yet. We built a map. Constance had known my father. Constance had been murdered by someone who let themselves in no forced entry, no defensive wounds, a victim who either knew the killer or had no reason to believe they were in danger. Constance will cut her children out entirely except for their childhood belongings. The grandfather clock contained something valuable enough to be untraceable and worth somewhere in the region of two hundred thousand pounds. The clock had been moved from the playroom meaning the children could not legally claim it. Someone had broken into my store looking for that clock. Someone wanted to kill me for it, and the only person who knew the secret that clock held, the only person who was a link to my father was now dead and I was the main suspect of her murder. Will I be able to prove my innocence? Will I ever be able to know anything about my father? And how?